Choosing a Private Consultant & Navigating Insurance
Patients make arrangements to see a doctor in private practice, in general to have control over:
- which doctor they see;
- when they are seen; and
- where they are seen.
When private medicine works well, the patient is able to choose an expert best suited to their needs.
Payment - Insurance or Self-Pay
Patients can fund private healthcare directly, or through an insurer (or other organisation, such as a mutual).
Self-pay
Self-paying patients cover the cost of their care usually by paying up front for services. Indeed, the majority of private practitioners, and nearly all fee-collecting services provided by private hospitals invoice at the time of booking. This approach has the advantage of ensuring costs are transparent, and that only patients who can afford the services book appointments.
Insurance
Various insurance products offer to spread the potential cost of private healthcare through monthly subscriptions. Many receive these products as a benefit of their employment.
The cost of insurance has increased, and continues to increase at a rate faster than average inflation. Between 2014 and 2024, premiums rose by an average of 5% per year, compared to average inflation of 2.9% per year, with a concomittant increase in profits.
Patients funding their private healthcare through an insurer face complexities linked to how practitioners are paid. These include a need to:
- check their product covers the practitioner and service they seek;
- in many instances (commonly with AXA, AVIVA and BUPA fee-assured schemes), agree to only specific “pre-approved”* practitioners;
- provide accurate insurer details in advance for the service;
- after the appointment check if any follow-on care or investigations are covered before agreeing;
- pay any proportion of the fee not covered by the insurer - usually managed as an excess invoice which arrives weeks after the consultation.
* pre-approval here usually means the practitioner is paid lower fees than other practitioenrs.
As a result of these complexities, many practitioners are either not seeing insured patients, restricting the number that they see, or introducing additional conditions to bookings made by insured patients (e.g. a requirement to provide card details for the payment of any excess).
Choosing a Private Consultant
The Private Healthcare Information Network, recommends considering the following when choosing a consultant are:
- their registration (and the registration for the facility - e.g. with the Care Quality Commission),
- their reputation - i.e. testimonials and verified reviews on platforms like Doctify, Topdoctor, or Google Reviews,
- their specialisation, and
- transparency about costs.
In addition to patient-based reviews and testimonials, the reputation of the doctor amongst other doctors and experts can also be important. This can be ascertained from:
- the opinion of a local (referring) GP,
- recommendations from other specialists,
- recognition through national leadership roles, or invitations to speak at national or international conferences,
- good quality peer-reviewed research publications.
Patient experience factors, which are almost never discussed/shared, but which influence the success of a consultation are:
- will pre-appointment information be reviewed by the consultant beforehand (e.g. previous test results, letters and scans)? A referral letter and relevant background information shared and reviewed before the appointment help to increase the chance of success. The consultation can therefore be focused on moving forward to address the patient’s goals, rather than chasing items of information from the past.
- how long is the appointment? Often this is not clear, or explicitly stated. Most neurologists allow either 30 or 40 minutes between new patient appointments. 30 minutes between patients usually translates to consultations of around 20 to 25 minutes each, which is suitable for standard and less complex consultations.
- when will the clinic letter be released? The wait between an appointment and the finalised clinic letter varies markedly across doctors - e.g. from less than 1 day, to 2 weeks. For some patients, the information is needed to inform next steps such as travel. It may therefore be useful to seek this information in advance of being seen.
Specialisation and Expertise
A common view is that specialists have more insight into problems than “generalists”. This view is, however, correct if and only if the problem is narrowly and specifically within the specialist’s domain.
As patients seldom come with a diagnosis, but instead a set of symptoms which need to be understood, the best place to start is almost always with a doctor with a general and broad understanding of medicine. This is why patients seeing private consultants do well in almost all instances to see a *general *practitioner first.
Within specialties in medicine (e.g. neurology), there is an increasing tendency to further subdivision into narrower domains of interest (e.g. multiple sclerosis neurology, headache neurology, or epilepsy). Part of this is a practical consequence of just how common some problems are (e.g. migraine affects 12 in 100 adults). Special interest, and subspecialty experience should not however replace skill and expertise in managing patients whose problems have yet to be fully defined.
In my experience, patients presenting with new symptoms are best served by consultants with a broad, rather than narrow experience base both within general practice, and in medical specialties. For the few occasions where subspecialty input is needed, further referrals can thereafter be made.